A very typical and also expensive error that food brands make is to think that a recipe that has been tested and has worked nicely in the lab will act the same way in the factory. The Scale-up food formulation looks good on paper. The taste, texture, and appearance are all perfect in small batches. But the moment large-scale production starts, the problem arises.
There are changes in the texture. There is a drop in the flavour. The shelf life decreases. The costs increase. The product is no longer consistent.
Want to optimise your Food Business? Request a free consultation!
Food Product Development Services – Click Here
This difference between a successful lab trial and a failed commercial run is where many promising products lose their momentum. It is the idea that is rarely the problem, according to our experienced food consultants. The misunderstanding of the difference between lab food recipes and a true Factory recipe, and the unplanned early scale-up food formulation are the real issues.
This blog explains the reasons behind Lab Recipe Fails, the difficulties that the lab and factory present, and how brands can prevent that gap from becoming an expensive lesson.
The Illusion of a “Perfect” Lab Recipe
In the laboratory, the environmental factors are totally under control. The substances are measured very accurately, combined so as not to disturb and worked through very small devices. The time is not a constraint, and whenever necessary, the modifications can be made at once. Such conditions of the laboratory are very suitable for testing, the use of imagination and the development of new Food formulation in the first place.
Lab testing is a must. They are the first step in the Research & Development process, and they provide the very boundaries for the definition of flavour, texture, and product identity. However, lab trials are not intended to mirror the true constraints of manufacturing or successful scale-up food formulation.
The issue begins when the lab recipe is considered a final product rather than a prototype.
The lab recipe poses the question: Is the product doable?
The factory recipe poses a different question: Is the product doable, consistent, affordable, and safe at large scale through proper scale-up food formulation?
One mixing of the two is one of the main reasons why the brands face problems in getting through the commercialisation process.
Why Lab Recipes Behave Differently at Factory Scale
1. Equipment Changes Everything
In a lab environment, the mixing process can be conducted through tabletop blenders or small kettles. On the other hand, the factory context involves industrial mixers, continuous cookers, extruders, or high-shear systems. Each of these machines produces various forces, temperatures, and timings.
Under these conditions, the ingredients will respond differently. For instance, proteins may become denatured to a larger extent, emulsions may go through disruption, and particulates may get unevenly settled. A batch that remained stable in the lab could turn out scaled-up to be quite tricky to manage.
In fact, this is the very reason why the scale-up food formulation cannot be as straightforward as simply multiplying the quantities; it involves the redesigning of the process itself.
2. Ingredient Behaviour Shifts with Volume
Ingredients that are not compatible with each other often show poor relations in small-batch formulations. But in large-scale production, the same ingredients might behave differently because of longer holding times, higher shear, and even heat transfer.
Common problems are:
- Separation in sauces or beverages
- Grittiness in protein-rich products
- Off-notes emerging after processing.
- Loss of functional claims during heat treatment
If these issues are not taken care of in the Food Research & Development phase of food formulation, the factory will be the testing ground, an expensive and hazardous place to conduct experiments.
3. Time Is a Critical Variable at Scale
In a Food Testing Laboratory, one is able to rapidly transition between different operations. However, in a manufacturing unit, materials could be stored in different places, like tanks, pipelines, or hoppers, for a considerable amount of time. This light impact could lead to changes in microbial stability, oxidation, and texture.
A formulation that appears to be stable for 30 minutes in the laboratory may become unfit after two hours on a production line. The time factor is frequently neglected in the early stages of Food formulation, but it has a huge impact on the quality of the final product during scale-up food formulation.
The Hidden Cost of Ignoring Factory Reality
Repeated production failures are a common experience with many brands before they approach us. At that moment, they have already put money into materials, packing, advertising, and production.
Not considering factory realities results in:
- Excessive reformulation cycles
- Launches pushed back
- More waste
- Quitting the manufacturer’s trust
This entire situation could have been avoided if, from the very beginning, the product had been designed with mass, scale-up food formulation in mind.
Final Thoughts
A fantastic product idea requires a fantastic execution. If your product dies in large numbers, it is seldom due to the weakness of the idea; it is just that the transition from laboratory to factory was not estimated accurately.
Realising the difference between laboratory food compositions and an authentic Factory composition is necessary for any sincere food brand. With an appropriate Research & Development setup and an intelligent manner of Food formulation, scale-up food formulation turns out to be a planned step ahead, not a painful shock.
If you expect your product to survive beyond the lab and be successful in the market, scaling must be a topic of discussion from the very first day.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the reason for lab recipes failing during factory production?
The lab recipes are made in a controlled environment, but on the other hand, in a factory production, the heat, shear, time, and even the type of machinery are all factors that influence the evolution of the ingredients.
How do factory recipes differ from lab recipes?
Lab recipe is for trial and error, but the factory recipe is made to be consistent, cheap, safe, and suitable for large-scale production.
What does scale-up food formulation entail?
Scale-up food formulation refers to the task of making a recipe and a process that are no longer tied to the original lab conditions but instead are controlled by the factory conditions in terms of both consistency and economy.
Is it possible to directly scale a lab recipe for commercial production?
Absolutely not, Direct scaling very often leads to failures of texture, flavour, and stability, which could have been avoided with proper pilot trials and process validation.
What causes food texture to alter when scaling up?
The changes in equipment, mixing intensity, heating rate, and holding time can have a paramount effect on proteins, emulsions, and stabilisers.
What are the largest mistakes made during food scale-up?
One of the biggest mistakes is skipping pilot trials; also, ignoring the restrictions of the equipment, underestimating ingredient interactions, and not planning for costs at the scale of production.
How significant are pilot trials in food formulation?
Pilot trials are very important as they help to identify any issues that might arise in large-scale production by mimicking the factory conditions.
Could scaling up harm the shelf life of food?
Definitely, if not properly tested, processing stress, oxygen exposure and moisture changes at scale can greatly shorten the shelf life.
When in product development should scaling planning start?
The scaling planning should commence during R&D and not after the lab recipe has been approved.
Should the process of food formulation scaling be assisted by a consultant?
Certainly. The involvement of scale-up specialists ensures the laboratory production of food recipes being transformed into stable, factory-ready formulations, and they also prevent the occurrence of expensive failures.
