How We Solved the Bitter Aftertaste in a Sugar-Free Beverage – A Real Formulation Case Study

May 23, 2025

Meet the leader of the beverage formulation industry. Driven by Innovation, Perfected by Experience — Explore Foodsure’s latest case study. Being the leading beverage industry provider, we don’t just follow trends — we create them. With a sharp focus on taste, health, and functionality. Backed by results: we’ve delivered over 500+ successful formulations across beverages, snacks, and health foods.

Check out our case studies to see how we help create tasty, healthy beverage products that people love and brands are proud to launch.

The Challenge: Sugar Free Beverages

Challenges are something that is always going to be a way to launch successful beverage products. See what we went through with our top clients.

We were working with a client who wanted to launch a sugar-free beverages, natural drink using stevia as the sweetener. It looked like a great idea on paper—zero calories, plant-based, and clean-label. The story doesn’t end here. There was a big problem:

The drink had a strong metallic aftertaste.
It left a bitter flavor in the mouth.
The sensory panel rejected it instantly.

This is a very common issue when using stevia in sugar-free beverages. So what did we do? We took a deep dive into taste science and rebuilt the formula using smarter ingredients. But wait, why does stevia sometimes taste bitter? This needs to come out; let’s move on to this.

Why Stevia Sometimes Tastes Bitter

Let’s unpack this from a food science point of view.

Stevia is derived from the leaves of Stevia rebaudiana, a plant known for its intensely sweet glycosides, especially Rebaudioside A, which can be up to 300–400 times sweeter than sugar.

But here’s the science-backed truth:

Most commercial stevia products (especially low-grade ones) contain a mix of steviol glycosides—some of which carry harsh, bitter, or metallic notes that the human tongue picks up, especially at higher concentrations.

And the bitterness can amplify when paired with fruity acids like citric or malic acid, commonly found in beverages.

Why Stevia Sometimes Tastes Bitter — Tastes Bitter

Our 3-Step Smart Formulation Strategy That Changed Everything

To change the drink from a sensory failure to a market-ready success, we implemented a targeted, scientific approach, including ingredient upgrades, sweetener synergy, and bitterness suppression.

Step 1: Upgraded the Stevia – Rebaudioside A 97% (High Purity)

Instead of using a generic stevia extract (which usually contains 50–80% purity), we upgraded to Reb A 97%, one of the cleanest-tasting and most refined steviol glycosides available.

Why it works:

Higher purity = fewer bitter compounds
Closer to sucrose in taste profile
Better solubility and heat stability

Pro Tip: Always check the purity and source of your stevia with a COA (Certificate of Analysis). Purity makes a huge difference in taste and stability.

Step 2: Added Erythritol for Mouthfeel, Sweetness Balance, and Cooling Effect

One of the major drawbacks of stevia is that while it provides sweetness, it lacks body and texture. This makes beverages feel thin or artificial.

We introduced erythritol, a natural sugar alcohol that:

Adds mild sweetness and a slight cooling effect
Mimics sugar’s mouthfeel and body
It is non-caloric and tooth-friendly
Has a clean metabolic profile (safe for diabetics)

Why this matters

It levels up the overall flavor perception
Reduced stevia’s dominance
Created a rounded, full-bodied beverage experience

Step 3: Introduced Glycine – A Natural Bitterness Blocker

After improving the stevia and adding erythritol, there was still a subtle bitterness in the background. That’s where we added the finishing touch—glycine, a naturally occurring amino acid that’s often used as a bitterness masker.

Glycine’s role in flavor modulation:

Acts on taste receptors to suppress bitterness
Doesn’t add flavor, but changes how flavors are perceived.
Enhances smoothness in stevia-based formulas

Result: A clean, pleasant aftertaste with no lingering bitterness—perfect for fruit-forward and herbal beverages.

Our 3-Step Smart Formulation Strategy That Changed Everything — Smart Formulation Strategy That Changed Everything

The Result: A Sugar-Free Beverages That Tastes Just Right

After reformulating, we tested the drink again with the sensory panel. Here’s what they said:

No more bitterness
No metallic aftertaste
Clean, balanced sweetness
Tastes like a lightly sweetened, natural drink

As per the include Sensory Panel Stats or Quotes. Results: Panel approval rating: 92% post-reformulation vs. 17% before.

The drink was approved, and the client was thrilled. What started as a failed formula is now a market-ready, consumer-friendly sugar-free product. And this shows reformulation of beverages can be game-changing.

If you are stuck on something that is not working, don’t worry, we are here to help. Just Book a Free 15-minute Consultation Now.

The Result A Sugar Free Drink That Tastes Just Right — Sugar-Free Drink That Tastes Just Right

What You Can Learn From This Case Study

Every challenge has new learning not only for us, but for many like us. If you’re a beverage brand or a product developer, here are the key lessons for beverage formulation:

1. Don’t Compromise on Sweetener Quality

Always use high-purity stevia like Reb A 97%. It makes a huge difference in taste.

2. Blend Smartly – Don’t Use Stevia Alone

Stevia works best in blends. Combine it with erythritol or other natural sweeteners to improve texture and taste.

3. Use Bitterness Blockers Wisely

Ingredients like glycine are game-changers. They don’t add flavor but improve the way flavors are perceived.

4. Taste Testing Is Everything

Sensory panels are critical. A few tweaks can turn a rejected product into a bestseller.

Our Expert Tip for New Beverage Brands

When working with sugar-free or clean-label products, taste should never be sacrificed. Most brands focus only on removing sugar, but the real win is when you remove sugar and keep the taste that customers love.

Read More: Boost Your Beverage Brand Globally

“Every failed taste is a lesson. Every rejection is a redirection. What sets us apart is not that we avoid challenges, but that we solve them so well, they become our signature.”

Founder’s Note, Foodsure

Want to Create a Winning Sugar-Free Product?

Bitter aftertaste? Broken formulas? Finding solutions? Partner with Foodsure, we engineer taste breakthroughs that redefine what’s possible. Whether it’s reformulating bitter stevia or designing your next bestseller from scratch, we build products that customers crave and brands are proud to launch.